Maggie Appleton:
I don’t think design engineering means making fancy micro-interactions and posting them on Twitter
Dayum — shots fired! But also: agree 1000%!!
Wait, so what is a “design engineer” exactly?
My preferred definition is a designer deeply involved in the technical craft and material of software. You’re a designer, but you help make decisions about functionality and architecture in code.
Also, lol for this great take on San Fran:
When I go to San Francisco – which I officially hate – everyone has theories. You go to a party and people tell you their theories, though often they’re all the same one.
Rach Smith, quoting my post, gets at things more succinctly than I did:
I remember when Google Search gave great results, when Facebook and Instagram genuinely kept me connected to my friends' lives, and when Twitter was a fun place to network and make connections in the industry. Every single one turned to shit in pursuit of profit.
Yes, exactly! How long?
How long until the incentives begin changing? What company can resist the ability to print money from other companies eager to influence generative output? (And how transparent will that be?)
Bill Gates:
We may need to develop the taste to actually not use technology to its maximum.
Everyone’s talking about how important “taste” is in making software nowadays.
What about the taste to not make software?
We have had groups — not large groups, but like the Amish — who don’t live at the technology frontier. A lot of humanity may choose not to live at the technological frontier because of things we get from helping each other
Now those are two ideas I can get behind:
- Maybe we shouldn’t saturate every aspect of our lives with tech.
- Maybe we could learn a thing or two from the Amish.
Bryan Cantrill talking about a video he recorded at Google Tech Talks in 2007
If you think I am candid now, you should’ve heard me when the video cameras weren’t rolling, it was something else. When no one could live-tweet what I said, it was more candid.
It is interesting to think about how much technology shapes our conversations with each other.
When everybody can consume everybody else’s conversations, what does that mean for what we say to each other?
(For example, what a speaker says at a conference might be very different if that talk is not recorded, vs. if they know that talk will be recorded, broadcast, and archived on the web for the rest of their lives.)
Oh, and I liked this part too where Bryan talks about why companies should write down what they do:
Record things you don’t otherwise record. In comments (where appropriate), in videos (where appropriate), record these things, not just for future generations but also because it allows a sourcespace to project its values. “Here’s what we’re about.” When people want to come work at Joyent, I have them go watch a couple of videos so they know what they’re getting in to. I tell people, “I have a couple videos […] if you watch them, you will want to work here more or less but you will not want to work here the same.” By doing that, you allow people to opt-in to your traditions and your values. It leads to more success in hiring, you get a more diverse team […] because the values you have transcend the traditional ways you hire people.
You can totally see this ethos being lived at Bryan’s company Oxide, like in their RFDs.
It pains me to link to LinkedIn, but for a Rich Hickey take I’ll do it.
He calls out referring to AI as a “tool”:
As a lifelong tool builder and user, I know what tools are. LLMs are not tools [...] LLMs are automation.
Shots fired!
You don't direct the action of an LLM - you make requests and it acts on its own, without your energy or continuous direction
You have traded working with the world to working for a capricious robot.
What have we lost?
What do you miss by abdicating doing the reading? Pretty much everything. First and foremost, you miss learning how to write from those who can. You miss learning how to formulate an argument. You miss noticing things. You miss loading your background mind with fodder for novel ideas. You miss building trust in some authors and suspicion of others. You miss all the jokes. You miss all of the edges. You miss learning how to think.
(I love his point about how AI is not a “tool” for reading the same way a Kindle is a “tool” for reading or “glasses” are tools for reading. Just read the whole thing.)
Lastly:
Tools don't get "misaligned", they don't "go rogue", they don't "escape containment", "conspire" etc.
It just reeks of the offloading of responsibility. “I was mindlessly cutting an apple and the knife in my hand escaped containment and cut my finger. Not my fault!”
Sean Voisen (emphasis mine):
This means specifically telling the agent to actually use the intended design system, use these components in such and such a way, use these colors for these purposes and not other purposes, always lay out elements in this fashion using these pre-defined spacing tokens, avoid inventing new components, and so forth and so on. Constraining generation shrinks the disturbance variety of the whole system by reducing what’s possible.
This vibes with my experience (pun intended).
Being an editor and “constraining generation” for the LLM seems like the primary function.